2026 Holiday Gift Guide | The Paper Store

The 2026 Holiday Gift Guide is here! | Shop Gift Guide

It's cozy season! Check out the Dream Shop | Shop Now

New squishy arrivals are in! Shop Now

Search In-Store Only

Search In-Store Only

SANTA CLAUS IS COMING TO TOWN! SEE WHEN HE'S VISITING YOUR LOCAL STORE

Festive holiday gifts, wrapped presents, ornaments, and cozy accessories arranged in a Christmas display.

the holiday gift guide

SHOP CHRISTMAS SHOP HANUKKAH

best gifts in the game

Woman in a red holiday sweater holding a festive gift.

GIFTS FOR HER →

Two men holding Yetis and wearing casual sweaters and jackets outdoors.

GIFTS FOR HIM →

Teen girl painting in an Emily Lex Stdio watercolor book.

GIFTS FOR TEENS →

Two young children sitting together in festive holiday outfits holding Bukowski stuffed animals.

GIFTS FOR KIDS →

Assorted holiday stocking stuffers, including small gifts, accessories, and festive treats.

stocking stuffers

Wrapped Christmas presents with colorful ribbons, bows, and gift wrap.

finishing touches

Gifts Under $25

Gifts Under $50

Gifts Under $75

Stocking Stuffers

DEAL

SHOP NOW →

DEAL

SHOP NOW →

SHOP ALL DEALS →

SHOP ALL DEALS →

the merry market

Festive holiday mantel display featuring nutcrackers, Christmas trees, candles, and seasonal decorations.er

Decorative Frame

festive home

Assorted Christmas figurines and miniature holiday decorations.

SHOP SNOWFLAKE LANE →

Holiday Willow Tree figurines arranged on a neutral background.

SHOP SENTIMENTAL →

Festive holiday Alight candles

BUY 1, GET 1

free

Alight Large Jar Candles

SHOP CANDLES →

Holiday glitter lanterns and decorative gifts in neutral tones.

SHOP GLITTER LANTERNS →

Festive holiday table setting with seasonal Nora Fleming serveware, greenery, and Christmas decorations.

SHOP SERVEWARE →

Gift basket filled with Stonewall Kitchen crackers and savory spreads wrapped in cellophane.

SHOP GOURMET SNACKS →

Three festive holiday glasses featuring Christmas trees, snowflakes, and colorful seasonal designs.

SHOP GLASSWARE →

Four ceramic holiday mugs featuring Christmas trees, snowflakes, candy canes, and winter designs.

BUY 1, GET 1

2 for $25

Holiday Mugs

Woman wearing a pink robe and patterned pajamas holding a wrapped holiday gift.

Buy 1 PJ Pant, Get 1 PJ Top

50% off

Alight Large Jar Candles

SHOP PAJAMAS & ROBES →

Stack of three cozy blankets featuring snowflakes, holly, and candy cane patterns.

$20

Legacy & Main Blankets

Alight Large Jar Candles

SHOP BLANKETS →

Assorted fuzzy socks in pastel colors tied together with a white ribbon.

BUY 1, GET 1

5 for $18

Cozy Socks & Butter Socks

SHOP SOCKS & SLIPPERS →

Four Marin Skincare lip treatments in blue, white, red, and green tubes.

SHOP BEAUTY & SPA →

Woman and two girls wearing cozy pajamas beside a decorated Christmas tree.

Decorative Frame

dream shop

Two young girls in matching red plaid pajamas playing with plush toys and holiday gifts.

your squishy headquarters

Decorative Frame

the toy box

Two young girls in matching red plaid pajamas playing with plush toys and holiday gifts.

your squishy headquarters

Decorative Frame

the toy box

your squishy headquarters

SHOP SQUISHIES

Male model wearing a tan shirt with a flag that says "in dad we trust", putting grilled hotdogs on a platter

festive home

Four women wearing cozy winter sweaters, scarves, and hats beside a vintage wood-paneled car.

Decorative Frame

holiday closet

Green knit cardigan with festive winter patterns and a wrapped holiday gift.

SHOP SWEATERS →

Assorted Kendra Scott earrings displayed in open jewelry boxes with red holiday ribbons.

SHOP JEWELRY →

Two Vera Bradley quilted bags in floral and black patterns, stacked with red gift ribbons.

BUY 1, GET 1

$36

Vera Bradley Ultimate Travel Case

SHOP ACCESSORIES →

Blue knit winter hats, gloves, and scarves featuring colorful Fair Isle patterns.

BUY 1, GET 1

free

Hats, Gloves & Scarves

SHOP WINTER ESSENTIALS →

Black knit cardigan with colorful sequins displayed with silver holiday tinsel.

SHOP HOLIDAY GLITZ →

Navy blue sweatshirt with red "Eating Junk & Watching Rubbish" lettering and plaid holiday ribbon.

SHOP CLASSIC CHRISTMAS →

Blue sweatshirt featuring a snowy mountain scene with ski gondolas and evergreen trees.

SHOP APRES SKI →

Red Fair Isle knit cardigan with festive winter patterns and a red satin ribbon.

SHOP FAIR ISLE →

Three Strawflower tote bags featuring colorful floral and block print patterns.

Three Strawflower cosmetic bags in green, blue, and pink block print patterns.

SHOP COSMETIC BAGS →

Two quilted Strawflower duffel bags featuring blue and multicolored floral patterns.

SHOP DUFFELS →

Three folded Strawflower blankets featuring colorful botanical block prints.

SHOP BLANKETS →

Assorted Strawflower quilted totes, cosmetic bags, and blankets in festive floral prints displayed beside a Christmas tree.

Decorative Frame

boutique

Male model wearing a tan shirt with a flag that says "in dad we trust", putting grilled hotdogs on a platter

festive home

Two men wearing casual fall layers and holding travel tumblers beside a vintage wood-paneled car.

men's shop

Assorted plaid pajama pants featuring NFL team logos, including the Bears, Celtics, Bruins, Patriots, and Bills.

SHOP FAN GEAR →

Duke Cannon Big Ass Brick of Soap bars in assorted scents, displayed with green ribbons.

SHOP STOCKING STUFFERS →

Assorted men's knit winter hats and patterned socks in seasonal colors.

BUY 1, GET 1

free

Polar Extreme Thermal Wear

SHOP WINTER ESSENTIALS →

Assorted YETI water bottles and tumblers in green, gray, red, and camouflage patterns.

SHOP DRINKWARE →

the nice list

what's in store

Colorful floral wall with a glowing neon “Ear Piercing” sign.

free

ear piercing

free ear piercing

with purchase of select studs.* Plus, 20% off your remaining purchase the day of piercing!

Close up of engraved water bottles

everything personalized

Add custom engraving, embroidery or embossing for a finishing touch that's all your own.

Santa Claus holding a stack of Christmas presents wrapped in festive red and green plaid paper with coordinating ribbons.

oh,

what fun!

what fun!

From Santa visits to embroidery and more, there's so much to celebrate in-store.

SANTA CLAUS IS COMING TO TOWN!

SEE WHEN HE'S VISITING YOUR LOCAL STORE

Festive holiday gifts, wrapped presents, ornaments, and cozy accessories arranged in a Christmas display.

the holiday gift guide

SHOP CHRISTMAS SHOP HANUKKAH

best gifts in the game

Woman in a red holiday sweater holding a festive gift.

GIFTS FOR HER →

best gifts in the game

Woman in a red holiday sweater holding a festive gift.

Assorted holiday stocking stuffers, including small gifts, accessories, and festive treats.

stocking stuffers

Wrapped Christmas presents with colorful ribbons, bows, and gift wrap.

finishing touches

Gifts Under $25

Gifts Under $50

Gifts Under $75

Stocking Stuffers

DEAL

SHOP NOW →

DEAL

SHOP NOW →

SHOP ALL DEALS →

SHOP ALL DEALS →

the merry market

the merry market

Festive holiday mantel display featuring nutcrackers, Christmas trees, candles, and seasonal decorations.

Decorative Frame

festive home

shop by category

Assorted Christmas figurines and miniature holiday decorations.

SHOP SNOWFLAKE LANE →

Holiday Willow Tree figurines arranged on a neutral background.

SHOP SENTIMENTAL →

Woman and two girls wearing cozy pajamas beside a decorated Christmas tree.

Decorative Frame

dream shop

shop by category

Woman wearing a pink robe and patterned pajamas holding a wrapped holiday gift.

Buy 1 PJ Pant, Get 1 PJ Top

50% off

Alight Large Jar Candles

SHOP PAJAMAS & ROBES →

Stack of three cozy blankets featuring snowflakes, holly, and candy cane patterns.

$20

Legacy & Main Blankets

Alight Large Jar Candles

SHOP BLANKETS →

Woman and two girls wearing cozy pajamas beside a decorated Christmas tree.

Decorative Frame

the toy box

shop by category

Assorted colorful NeeDoh squishy toys and Swirl sensory toys with red gift ribbons.

SHOP SQUISHIES →

Assorted Jellycat plush animals, including a moose, bear, and festive stuffed toys.

SHOP STUFFED ANIMALS →

Four women wearing cozy winter sweaters, scarves, and hats beside a vintage wood-paneled car.

Decorative Frame

holiday closet

shop by category

Green knit cardigan with festive winter patterns and a wrapped holiday gift.

SHOP SWEATERS →

Assorted Kendra Scott earrings displayed in open jewelry boxes with red holiday ribbons.

SHOP JEWELRY →

Assorted Strawflower quilted totes, cosmetic bags, and blankets in festive floral prints displayed beside a Christmas tree.

Decorative Frame

boutique

shop by category

Three Strawflower tote bags featuring colorful floral and block print patterns.

Three Strawflower cosmetic bags in green, blue, and pink block print patterns.

SHOP COSMETIC BAGS →

Male model wearing a tan shirt with a flag that says "in dad we trust", putting grilled hotdogs on a platter

men's shop

shop by category

Life is Good Men's This Dad's Cooler Short Sleeve Crusher Tee in Vintage Blue

SHOP FAN GEAR →

Garage Beer Dog Short Sleeve Tee

SHOP STOCKING STUFFERS →

the nice list

what's in-store

Colorful floral wall with a glowing neon “Ear Piercing” sign.

free ear piercing

with purchase of select studs.* Plus, 20% off your remaining purchase the day of piercing!

Close up of engraved water bottles and embroidered cosmetic pouches

everything personalized

Add custom engraving, embroidery or embossing for a finishing touch that's all your own.

Santa Claus holding a stack of Christmas presents wrapped in festive red and green plaid paper with coordinating ribbons.

what fun!

From Santa visits to embroidery and more, there's so much to celebrate in-store.

2026 Holiday Gift Guide | The Paper Store